Pro rata share errors are among the most common CAM overcharges. Use this guide to recalculate your percentage and catch denominator mistakes.
Think your lease might have this issue? Run a free CAM audit to check.
Find My OverchargesCheck your own documents before you keep researching.
Find overcharges in your CAM reconciliation. Most audits complete in under 15 minutes.
Find My OverchargesSee a sample report firstA pro rata share is the percentage of shared building costs allocated to an individual tenant. It is calculated by dividing the tenant's leased square footage by the total rentable area used as the denominator. Errors in either number produce an inflated share that compounds across every year of the lease.
Pro rata share errors are one of the most common and financially significant overcharge categories in commercial CAM billing. The error does not require any landlord misconduct: a denominator pulled from an outdated building record, applied inconsistently, or defined differently than the lease states is enough to overbill a tenant by thousands of dollars annually.
The formula is straightforward:
Pro Rata Share = Tenant RSF / Denominator RSF
The denominator definition is everything. Two tenants occupying the same 5,000 SF space can have different pro rata shares depending on how their leases define the denominator.
The Building Owners and Managers Association (BOMA) publishes measurement standards that define how rentable area is calculated. Different BOMA standards produce different square footage numbers for the same physical space. (Source)
| BOMA Standard | Primary Use Case | Key Difference |
|---|---|---|
| BOMA 2017 for Office Buildings | Office leases | R/U ratio methodology for common areas |
| BOMA 2010 for Retail | Retail and shopping center | Gross Leasable Area (GLA) methodology |
| BOMA 2024 (updated) | Mixed use, updated office | Revised load factor definitions |
| ICSC / GASC | Shopping centers | GLA excludes anchor stores by convention |
Why this matters: If your lease was executed under BOMA 2017 and the landlord remeasures under BOMA 2024, your tenant RSF may change without any physical change to your space. A denominator increase from remeasurement can reduce your share; a tenant RSF increase from remeasurement increases your share. Either change affects your annual bill.
The most common error. Landlords sometimes use total building square footage when the lease specifies only leasable area, or vice versa. The difference between gross building area and rentable leasable area in a typical office building is 10% to 20%. A denominator that is 15% smaller than it should be inflates every tenant's share by a proportional amount.
How to check: Pull the denominator definition from your lease. It will describe what area is included and excluded. Common language includes "total rentable area of the Building," "Gross Leasable Area of the Shopping Center," or "total leasable area of the Development, excluding anchor tenants." Recalculate using the number that matches that definition.
In retail shopping centers, anchor tenants (large box stores, grocery stores) often negotiate to be excluded from the CAM denominator. This exclusion is supposed to match a corresponding exclusion of their space from the CAM expense pool. When landlords exclude the anchor's square footage from the denominator without making a matching reduction to the expense pool, the remaining tenants absorb costs that serve the anchor's space.
Example:
Building square footage changes: expansions, demolitions, re-certifications under new BOMA standards, and partial-building sales can all change the denominator. A landlord who applies a denominator from a 10-year-old building record that has since changed is either overbilling or underbilling tenants depending on the direction of the change.
Some landlords calculate pro rata share using occupied area rather than total leasable area. If a building is at 75% occupancy, the denominator shrinks and each occupied tenant's share increases. This shifts vacancy costs to existing tenants, which is generally not permitted unless the lease explicitly includes a gross-up or vacancy adjustment provision.
Search your lease for: "pro rata share," "proportionate share," "tenant's share," or "CAM share." The definition will specify what RSF is used as the denominator. Common lease language:
Request building square footage records from the landlord. The audit rights clause in most commercial leases permits this request. Alternatively, compare the landlord's stated denominator to public records, BOMA certifications, or the building's original certificate of occupancy.
Divide your lease-specified Tenant RSF by the denominator RSF from Step 2. Compare to the landlord's stated percentage. A discrepancy of more than 0.1% is a legitimate dispute item.
If the landlord's share exceeds your correct share, multiply the difference by the total allocable expenses for the year. That is your annual overcharge.
Formula: (Landlord's % - Correct %) × Total Allocable Expenses = Annual Overcharge
Pro rata share disputes reach court when landlords and tenants disagree about which definition governs: the one written in the lease, or the one the landlord applied in practice.
In Payless Shoesource, Inc. v. Joye (E.D. Cal. 2014), the court examined a lease that allocated CAM based on tenant square footage divided by "total GLA of completed buildings within the Development." When a partial building sale occurred, the question was whether the denominator changed. The case illustrated how a single word in the denominator definition ("Development" vs. "Building") can produce dramatically different allocation results. (Source)
Retail CAM disputes involving anchor exclusions follow a consistent pattern in commercial real estate case law: when an anchor tenant's square footage is excluded from the denominator without a corresponding expense pool adjustment, remaining tenants are allocated a share larger than their economic use warrants. Courts have consistently found that landlords cannot deviate from the lease-defined denominator without breaching the contract. Anchor exclusion errors are not just common; they are litigable.
These decisions reinforce a key practical point: the denominator definition in your lease is controlling, and landlords cannot deviate from it without triggering a breach of contract claim.
The Building Owners and Managers Association released updated measurement standards in 2024. The 2024 revision modifies how certain shared spaces (lobbies, corridors, mechanical rooms) are allocated between rentable and non-rentable categories. For office tenants, this means the denominator RSF under BOMA 2024 may differ from the denominator under BOMA 2017 for the same building. (Source)
Three scenarios where BOMA 2024 affects pro rata share:
Scenario 1: Lease references BOMA 2017 but landlord remeasures under BOMA 2024. If the lease specifies "BOMA 2017 for Office Buildings" as the measurement standard, the landlord cannot substitute BOMA 2024 measurements without an amendment. If the remeasured denominator is smaller, your share increases. If larger, your share decreases. Either way, using a different standard than the lease specifies is a lease violation.
Scenario 2: Lease says "BOMA standard" without specifying a year. This is the ambiguous case. Some courts apply the standard in effect at lease execution; others apply the current standard. If the landlord remeasures under 2024 and your share changes, the dispute will turn on lease interpretation. Document the original denominator and the change.
Scenario 3: New lease post-2024. Leases executed after 2024 should specify the applicable BOMA standard. Tenants negotiating new leases should ensure the denominator is explicitly locked to a specific measurement standard and year to prevent future remeasurement disputes.
A scenario that produces recurring denominator errors: when a building has significant vacancy, some landlords calculate pro rata share based on occupied area rather than total leasable area. The denominator shrinks when occupancy is low, which increases each remaining tenant's share.
Example:
Unless the lease explicitly provides for an occupancy-based denominator or includes a gross-up provision, the landlord may not use occupied area as the denominator. The standard denominator is total leasable area, which allocates vacancy costs to the landlord rather than to remaining tenants.
The CAMAudit Pro Rata Share Calculator accepts four inputs:
The calculator returns your correct percentage, the delta versus the landlord's stated percentage, and the annual overcharge estimate. If the landlord's stated percentage is within 0.1%, the result is marked within rounding tolerance.
What is pro rata share in a commercial lease?
Pro rata share is the percentage of shared building costs allocated to an individual tenant. It is calculated by dividing the tenant's rentable square footage by the total denominator area defined in the lease. The denominator definition varies by lease and determines what portion of the building's costs the tenant is responsible for.
What is the most common pro rata share error?
The most common error is using the wrong denominator. This includes: using occupied area instead of total leasable area, using total building area when the lease specifies only leasable area, or excluding anchor tenant square footage from the denominator without making a corresponding reduction to the expense pool.
How do I find the denominator for my pro rata share?
The denominator is defined in your lease's pro rata share provision. Search for 'pro rata share,' 'proportionate share,' or 'tenant's share.' The definition specifies what square footage is used: the full building, leasable area only, a specific portion of a development, or leasable area excluding anchor tenants. Use that definition to identify the correct denominator RSF.
How does an anchor tenant exclusion affect my pro rata share?
When an anchor tenant's square footage is excluded from the denominator, the remaining tenants' shares increase because they divide into a smaller pool. If the anchor's corresponding expenses are not also excluded from the CAM pool, smaller tenants absorb costs that serve the anchor's space. This is one of the most costly pro rata share errors in retail shopping centers.
How much can a pro rata share error cost me?
A 1% denominator error on $400,000 in annual CAM expenses produces a $4,000 annual overcharge. Over a 5-year lease, that is $20,000. Anchor exclusion errors in large retail properties can produce overcharges of $5,000 to $50,000 per year depending on property size and the percentage of costs attributable to the anchor's space.
Pro rata share fundamentals:
Dispute:
Tools:
