GSA Cincinnati federal building: dollar-cap management fee overcharge case study
A public-record CAM case study showing $25,500 in management fee overcharges on a GSA lease: landlord billed $67,500 against a $42,875 absolute dollar cap.
What happened
The GSA lease at 36 E. 7th Street, Cincinnati fixed the management fee at a hard dollar cap of $42,875 per year. The 2022 reconciliation billed $67,500, which is $25,500 above the cap. No percentage formula applied; the dollar ceiling was absolute. The discrepancy was identified through FOIA Request #2023-GS-0081.
Findings from the pipeline
Rule 3: Management Fee Overcharge
high confidence
$25,500
Management fee of $67,500.00 exceeds the dollar cap of $42,875 Overcharge: $25,500.00.
Lease evidence
Management Fee shall not exceed $42,875 per calendar year. Section 8.2(b).
Section 8.2(b), page 15
Math proof
billed=67500.00, dollar_cap=42000.00, overcharge=25500.00
Lease evidence
- Management fee capped at $42,875 per calendar year (absolute dollar cap, Section 8.2(b)).
- NNN lease: tenant responsible for 8% pro-rata share of operating expenses.
Why this matters for your firm
Dollar-cap management fee violations are harder to spot than percentage caps because they require knowing the cap amount and comparing it to the absolute dollar billed, not just checking the rate. Federal leases are a rich source of these overcharges because the cap amounts are fixed at execution and rarely indexed.
Correction package excerpt
Request for Cooperative Review of Certain Line Items. The automated review flagged an apparent discrepancy of $25,500.00 for the 2022 reconciliation year: management fee exceeds the $42,875 annual dollar cap.
Frequently Asked Questions
Run these same detection rules on your client engagements
Upload a client lease and reconciliation. CAMAudit applies the same rule set used in this case study and delivers findings in under 15 minutes, with white-label report delivery under your firm brand.
Apply for partner accessPublic-record note
This page summarizes public-record documents and CAMAudit output for educational and marketing purposes. It does not imply endorsement by General Services Administration or any third party. Readers should review the underlying lease, statement, and dispute timeline for their own facts.